Meghan’s letter to her father ‘to defend charges of being unloving daughter’

The Duchess of Sussex is suing the publisher of The Mail On Sunday and MailOnline over articles which reproduced parts of a handwritten letter.

Meghan’s letter to her father ‘to defend charges of being unloving daughter’

The Duchess of Sussex’s letter to her estranged father was written “to defend her against charges of being an uncaring or unloving daughter”, the Mail on Sunday’s lawyers have told the High Court.

Meghan, 39, is suing the publisher of The Mail On Sunday and MailOnline over a series of articles which reproduced parts of the handwritten letter sent to 76-year-old Thomas Markle in August 2018.

Her lawyers say the publication of an “intrinsically private, personal and sensitive” letter was a “plain and serious invasion” of her privacy and argue Associated Newspapers Limited (ANL) has “no prospect” of defending her privacy and copyright claims.

However, ANL claims Meghan wrote the letter “with a view to it being disclosed publicly at some future point” and that she was “at least in some measure prepared for the information to be disclosed”.

Duchess of Sussex
The duchess is seeking damages from Associated Newspapers (Simon Dawson/PA)

But, at a two-day remote hearing on Tuesday, ANL’s barrister Antony White QC argued that “there is a very real question as to whether the claimant will be able to establish that she had a reasonable – or any – expectation of privacy”.

Mr White said in written submissions that Meghan’s admission she had “a fear” that her letter to her father might be intercepted showed that “she must, at the very least, have appreciated that her father might choose to disclose it”.

He also referred to the involvement of the Kensington Palace communications team before the letter was sent, saying: “No truly private letter from daughter to father would require any input from the Kensington Palace communications team.”

Justin Rushbrooke QC, representing the duchess, earlier described the hand-written letter as “a heartfelt plea from an anguished daughter to her father”, which was sent to Mr Markle at his home in Mexico via “the claimant’s accountant … to minimise the risk of interception”.

He said the “contents and character of the letter were intrinsically private, personal and sensitive in nature” and that Meghan therefore “had a reasonable expectation of privacy in respect of the contents of the letter”.

Mr Rushbrooke added in written submissions: “It is as good an example as one could find of a letter that any person of ordinary sensibilities would not want to be disclosed to third parties, let alone in a mass media publication, in a sensational context and to serve the commercial purposes of the newspaper.”

The barrister argued that “there is no real prospect of the defendant establishing that the claimant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in relation to the contents of the letter and the defendant’s contentions to the contrary are utterly fanciful”.

Court artist sketch of Mr Justice Warby
Court artist sketch of Mr Justice Warby during the hearing at the Royal Courts of Justice (Elizabeth Cook/PA)

But Mr White said in ANL’s written case that Meghan’s “status as a member of the royal family whose familial and personal relationships are in the public eye” was relevant.

He added that the “admitted falsity” of an article about Meghan in People magazine, which ANL says brought the letter to her father into the public domain, meant Mr Markle “was not only entitled to correct public information about the letter and the reply, it was in the public interest that (he) did so”.

Mr White argued: “Mr Markle has a right to tell his story of his relationship and communications with his daughter … no US court would stop him from doing so, and he could have and could still, whatever the outcome of this case, speak to the US media on this topic at any time.”

In relation to Meghan’s copyright claim, Ian Mill QC, also representing the duchess, argued that “she and she alone” created a draft of the letter to her father “which she then transcribed by hand”.

He argued the letter to Mr Markle was “an original literary work in which copyright subsists and is owned by the claimant” and asked the court to “grasp the nettle and decide the issue at this hearing”.

But Mr White argued there is “a real prospect that the claimant will fail to establish either that she was the sole author in the copyright sense” as a result of the involvement of Jason Knauf, formerly communications secretary to the Duke and Duchess of Sussex, in writing the letter.

The full trial of the duchess’s claim was due to be heard at the High Court this month, but last year the case was adjourned until autumn 2021 for a “confidential” reason.

The remote hearing before Mr Justice Warby is due to last two days and it is expected he will reserve his judgment to a later date.

Sorry, we are not accepting comments on this article.

Top Stories

More From The Guernsey Press

Business

Sam Field - Sure's Enterprise Solutions Product Manager discusses how the global pandemic and restrictions on movement have led to an increased dependency on digital services for both businesses and consumers, and to a large extent, pretty much everyone has had to adapt to new ways of working. Enforced lockdown has seen a massive rise in the use of collaboration services, and workforce transformations have taken place before our very eyes. Digital communications in whatever format have massively increased the amount of business data in circulation. Cybercriminals quickly identified dispersed working as a major opportunity, and have responded with pandemic themed scams and attacks to steal information and data. Whilst cyberattacks on individuals are very upsetting, they are generally easier to spot and deal with. A ‘take no action’ approach to any form of contact outside the norm is the key learning point on a personal level, and nobody can claim to be so smart they are not vulnerable. The workplace however is a much more complex environment with hierarchical relationships, managerial directives and business systems that aren’t always the simplest to operate. There’s a greater scope for cybercrime in organisations with operational complexity, and the value of data and information that can be stolen or extorted tends to be higher. Furthermore, it isn’t just criminals who are interested in business data. There are many business information platforms and other data centric organisations who are benefitting from the wealth of information flowing around the digital economy. And for many island organisations, protecting intellectual property (IP) from cybercriminals and other interested parties is vital. The arms race between data protection, criminals and legal data hunters is here for the long-haul as organisations strive to protect their businesses, customers, revenues and reputation. The focus still remains on cybercrime though, and the five overriding threats that are targeting hybrid working environments are: Email Phishing Defined as the fraudulent attempt to obtain sensitive information or data, such as usernames, passwords and credit card details, by disguising oneself as a trustworthy entity. Covid phishing activity often impersonates government and health authorities to deceive users into sharing confidential information such as payment and account credentials. When hackers break into corporate networks, they often take their time monitoring emails and activity, to maximise the impact of their attack. Criminals then mimic existing accounts and send emails instructing people to take action … do this, click here, update that, … all in an attempt to obtain the information and the access to funds they are looking for. SMS Phishing Also known as ‘Smishing’, is text messaging fraud that tries to lure victims into taking action. Clicking on links in texts can activate the downloading of malware that will reveal and extract sensitive account information. The increased use of smartphones for so much business activity exposes organisations to an extended perimeter, through a non-PC based zone of extended vulnerability. Fraudulent Domains Or domain spoofing, is also associated with phishing. Attackers use a ‘bogus domains’ to impersonate a company or its employees. This can be done by sending emails with false domain names which appear legitimate, or by setting up websites with slightly altered characters that look authentic, and asking you to take action that will compromise your security. Counterfeit Apps A counterfeit app is an app that claims to do something, but is actually fake, ineffective, or harmful to a user's device and information. They have been found on legitimate app stores including Apple and Google Play, where they have not yet been detected or reported. They aim to defraud users by offering fake functionality, and stealing data. Malware Malware is software that has been intentionally designed to cause damage or harm to a computer, server, client, or computer network - often for the purposes of extorting money. A wide variety of malware exist, including viruses, worms, trojan horses, ransomware, spyware, adware, rogue software, wiper and scareware. Malware exists for a number of reasons: such as causing malicious damage, and stealing financial details and sensitive information. Ransomware is a form of malware where attacks are designed to block access or take down sites until a sum of money is paid. Clear and Present Danger The average cost of a business cyberattack is estimated to be £3million, and around half of the cyberattacks involve email phishing, a figure that’s 20% higher than the global average. We partner with Mimecast, a ‘Gartner Magic Quadrant’ global cyber security leader, to provide a unique range of on and off-shore services. Cloud based, layered security provides advanced safeguarding and business continuity, protecting email and messaging services, along with access to your securely archived information. Download Sure's 'Creating your Digital Workplace’ here: https://business.sure.com/assets/Uploads/Brochures/08f06cfb91/Sure_digital_workplace.pdf Download 'Unified Communications' brochure: https://business.sure.com/assets/Uploads/News-downloads/2a8fc619e6/Sure_Unified-Communications-Article.pdf Find more information about Sure's portfolio of flexible working solutions: https://business.sure.com/products-and-services/flexible-working-solutions/ Sponsored content

UK & International News