Pensioner convicted of murder in oldest double jeopardy case

A pensioner has been found guilty of the vicious rape and murder of a teenager nearly 50 years ago in the oldest double jeopardy case in England and Wales.

Dennis McGrory was 28 when he sexually assaulted, stabbed and strangled 15-year-old Jacqui Montgomery in her home in Islington, north London, in 1975.

The next year, he was tried on a circumstantial case and cleared of murder on the directions of a judge.

Justice finally caught up with McGrory after swabs from Ms Montgomery’s body produced a one-in-a-billion DNA match decades later.

That trial, in March, was halted when McGrory, of Milton Keynes in Buckinghamshire, fell ill.

The pensioner appeared for his retrial Huntingdon Crown Court by video link and was found guilty of rape and murder.

The jury at Huntingdon Crown Court deliberated on Monday for just over an hour to find McGrory guilty on both charges against him.

The defendant was remanded into custody to be sentenced on January 13.

Prosecutor Sarah Przybylska had said: “No doubt furious with rage and wanting to attack Josie, the defendant took out his anger on the next best thing, Jacqui Montgomery, both raping and murdering her.”

During the attack, he ripped out a page of the teenager’s diary with her aunt’s address on it.

Jacqui’s body was found by her father, Robert Montgomery, lying on the floor of their living room in Offord Road in the early hours of June 2 1975.

She had suffered fatal stab wounds as well as blunt force trauma to the face and been strangled with the flex of an iron.

McGrory had threatened to rape Jacqui in the past and, on that night, he “made good” on those words, jurors were told.

Director of Public Prosecutions, Max Hill KC, hailed the guilty verdict, saying: “This crime took place a full decade before the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) opened its doors so it’s certainly the oldest case that I’ve encountered.

“It is one of the very small handful of double jeopardy cases that I’ve personally authorised to be taken to the Court of Appeal.

“We are very close now to the 50th anniversary of this crime so I’m particularly pleased that we’ve been able to bring this matter through to conviction after all these years.

“It is an extremely serious and rare step to ask the Court of Appeal, as I did, to set aside an acquittal for murder, whether that acquittal took place five years ago or 50 years ago.”

He told the PA news agency: “This was a particularly vicious murder of 15-year-old girl, where a sexual assault was part of the murderous attack.

“That meant that on further investigation, we were able to prove that there was a scientific link between McGrory and the body of Jacqueline Montgomery.

“His DNA was found on her body in circumstances where he denies to this day that he was even at the scene or at the house in which she was murdered.

“So that formed a really important new piece of evidence alongside the circumstantial evidence, which included finding on him at his arrest in 1975 a page torn from Jacqueline’s diary.

“When you put those two elements together, it became impossible for him to explain his possession of the diary page and the DNA sample that he left on this poor girl’s body in any way other than him being present and being the killer himself.”

He added: “Our thoughts are with all those who still mourn greatly and have suffered her loss – that is what drives investigators and prosecutors.

“Speaking as a lawyer, we don’t recognise any limitation of time on serious crime and the fact that a murder was committed five decades ago makes it no less important.

“In this case, McGrory at last now faces the prospect of the end of his life being spent behind bars.

“I’m sure that this individual McGrory believed that he had gotten away with murder. But since the double jeopardy principles were enshrined in statute in 2003, I and my recent predecessors have had the ability to try to put matters right.

“Although these cases are rightly very rare, where we see a significant miscarriage of justice, such as a wrongful acquittal for a murder, which was clearly committed, the message is: the system will catch you in the end. And that is what we’ve done in this case.”

“I hope that finally, the outcome at court has brought them some element of comfort.

“This has been an extremely challenging investigation lasting a number of years. The result and conviction at court in 2022, comes after seven years of real investigative work. The case officer has worked throughout that and with great dedication.

“McGrory was acquitted at court in 1976 but it was thanks to a forensic review, which came about following a request made by Jacqui’s family. That forensic review found DNA evidence and that was the new and compelling evidence that was brought by police and by prosecutors to the Court of Appeal, who agreed that he should stand trial again, which is what happened.

She added: “Members of her family gave evidence in this trial and they were extremely brave in doing so because McGrory was a violent bully who terrified the women in his life and that impact, that influence, was something that some of them still felt today.”

Claire Prodger, of the CPS London Homicide team, said: “Dennis McGrory has finally faced justice for his murderous actions all those years ago. He selfishly and brutally ended Jacqueline Montgomery’s life and must have thought he had escaped.

“The further evidence collected by the police, and used by the prosecution at trial, have made the jury today certain that he committed these crimes. He now faces the prospect of ending his life behind bars.”

Jacqui’s sister Kathy said: “A violent man who had been living within our family (raped and) murdered my sister. He has been able to live his life. He has spent nearly 50 years as a free man doing as he pleased.

“I find that unbearable when my sister didn’t even reach her 16th birthday. His actions caused trauma to so many people and there were no consequences for him.

“The investigation of the last few years has meant revisiting memories of the murder which has caused pain and stress for me and my family and I am relieved that we finally have justice for Jacqui.”