Education can’t afford to dismiss ideas

Some of the island’s most popular deputies have been dogmatic and cussedly determined that their way is the right way. No matter what the evidence and opposition they remain belligerently firm in their beliefs – and voters often love them for it.

Yet an open mind is a virtue. When picking a general to lead them to war what soldier would not want a leader with the ability to listen to all arguments and weigh up the best course of action? Better the pragmatist willing to admit error than the idealistic mule who keeps sending his or her men over the top regardless.

Education, Sport & Culture has been asked to consider two, loosely linked, ideas. Firstly, what would be the pros and cons of a two-school secondary system? Secondly, could the Forest School be merged with La Houguette?

Given the reaction from members of the political board it would be a miracle if either idea gets a proper hearing.

Despite being given £93,000 from Policy & Resources for staff to investigate a two-school system Education’s president was quick to throw a bucket of cold water over the concept. The island community, we were told, would not be in favour of two massive schools.

Regardless of the results, and expense, of that work, those championing the idea are going to have their work cut out persuading the board to take a considered view.

Likewise, the idea of merging the two primary schools. Although Education does not have to make a decision until 2020 two of its deputies have already ruled it out.

It is a principled stance no doubt, but both are from the Western parishes. As South-east deputy and former Education president Robert Sillars learned to his cost when closing St Andrew’s Primary it does not endear you to voters to close schools.

These are difficult days in Education. The island is split over the end of selection and the Budget is tight. There are no easy choices.

However, it would be comforting to know that ideas are not only being considered but given a fair hearing.