For one sweet minute last Friday, Guernsey vaguely resembled a model of financial responsibility. At 2.37pm, after four days of debate, the States of Deliberation approved Option A, the cheaper Budget. At 2.38pm, the minute was up, and they approved Option B, which costs £15.7m. more and takes its place.
Option A carried by 24 votes to 15; Option B carried by 23 to 12. The cheap Budget went to the vote first, so supporting it cost nothing, and eight deputies voted for both. Whichever plan survived, they had backed it, a technique previously confined to people who bet on both horses and then claim to have picked the winner.
The winning proposition also replaces January’s promise of 1% real-terms cuts in 2027, 2028 and 2029 with £20m. a year of savings ‘by 2029 (or as soon as possible thereafter)’. Members therefore voted, in a single sentence, to spend more now and to save later, the parliamentary equivalent of ordering a second pudding and promising to start the diet in 2029, or as soon as possible thereafter.
‘We measure debate in the traditional unit, which is the Gollop,’ said Pascal Le Ruez, the States’ newly-appointed clerk of minutes elapsed. ‘This week came to more than 200,000 words and more than 60 electronic votes. The two that mattered took a minute.’
1%, 0%
At the last election, Deputies Gavin St Pier, Rhona Humphreys and Tom Rylatt of Forward Guernsey promised to cut baseline spending by 1% a year, £25m. by 2029. It was the most precise promise of the campaign, and the trio spent the week keeping it away from any vote that might cost them something.
Deputies Humphreys and Rylatt tabled Option C, a compromise costing £7.85m. more than Option A and £7.85m. less than Option B, the political equivalent of ordering a lamb Madras instead of the vindaloo. It lost 12 to 26. All three also voted against Deputy Simon Vermeulen’s amendment to delete Option B, the week’s only proposal with any chance of stopping the extra £15.7m. from being spent.
On Wednesday, an extra £6.1m. for Health & Social Care fell by a single vote, 16 to 17. Four deputies declined to vote, and three of them were the Forward Guernsey deputies. The members who had promised to hold the line held their hands in their laps instead. By this stage the Bailiff was so exasperated that she was riffling through her purse to see whether she could muster the £6.1m. herself, if only to move things along.
On Friday, the trio voted for Option A. One minute later, with Option B on the screen and their manifesto on the line, all three pressed ‘je ne vote pas’. Over the week Deputy St Pier abstained 12 times, Deputy Rylatt 10 and Deputy Humphreys eight, and the party is understood to be considering a rebrand as Neutral Guernsey.
Spend less, spend lesser, spend more
Deputy Aidan Matthews told voters he would spend less. He then voted for nine amendments that would have cost about £11.7m. between them, seconded Friday’s cost-of-living payment, and finished the week by voting for Option B, the one that costs £15.7m. more.
Deputy Sarah Hansmann Rouxel voted in January for 1% real-terms cuts. On Friday, with those cuts in front of her as Option A, she voted against them and then for Option B. Her manifesto promised to cut duplication. She has started with her own votes.
Deputy Vermeulen, a member of Home Affairs, moved the deletion of Option B and voted for all three Home Affairs bids, on the well-established principle that cuts are best applied to other committees.
Deputy Mark Helyar, who also promised to spend less, voted for just two amendments all week that would have cost money, £1.8m. between them, and against Option B. Colleagues have asked him to stop, as he is making the rest of them look bad.
Promises kept, alarmingly
Deputy Tina Bury stood against cuts, then voted for amendments that would have cost about £21m., Option C included. On Friday she voted against Option A and for Option B. She is the first deputy this term to do in office exactly what she said in her manifesto. Apparently the States Assembly & Constitution Committee is understood to be looking into whether this is allowed.
Deputy Liam McKenna, who made no spending-restraint pledge at all, seconded the amendment to delete Option B and voted against Option B on Friday. Political scientists describe this as breaking a manifesto in the thrifty direction, a phenomenon previously thought to exist only in theory.
Talking points
On Tuesday, members twice voted against limiting the length of their own speeches, by 13 to 26 and 19 to 20. On Wednesday they agreed to six minutes, nine for proposers, by 25 to 13. Several treated this as a minimum.
Deputy Andy Sloan spoke more than anyone, about 15,200 words, roughly the length of a short novella in which a man asks for an economic impact assessment and is not given one.
Rising to sum up on Amendment 17, Deputy Sloan checked his allowance. ‘I don’t have six minutes, is it?’ he asked, and on being told it was nine, replied: ‘Oh, I can be slow then.’ He was the only one laughing.
Second place went to Deputy Marc Leadbeater on about 14,200 words, a total he reached while also being recorded as not voting in 13 votes. No reason was recorded. He proposed three Home Affairs amendments and lost all three, the most consistent law-and-order result of the week.
Deputy John Gollop came fifth on 10,700 words without proposing a single amendment. He opened Thursday afternoon by promising ‘to keep things tight and relevant’, and was talking about the Norwegian sovereign wealth fund and why Norway has not joined the European Union within 20 seconds. Another pledge broken.
Deputy Ozanne no-show
Deputy Ozanne missed all of Wednesday and Thursday morning, 19 votes in all, to sit an exam in the UK. It had been a busy week for the deputy. On the Monday she had given evidence in Westminster to the joint committee of both Houses examining the UK government’s draft bill to ban conversion practices. She told it that prayer aimed at changing someone’s sexuality should be criminalised, and that the bill had gone down a rabbit hole. On Friday she told the States that they had gone down one too. Some colleagues suggested that was where she had been on Wednesday.
A Dressing down on dress down Thursday
On Thursday morning members wore Guernsey jumpers for Les Bourgs Hospice, having ignored the Bailiff’s instruction to wear jackets on the way in. ‘I’m a little bit like the disappointed headmistress,’ she told them, which islanders felt was the most accurate statement made in the chamber all week. Members then sat for nine hours, about seven and a half of them in debate, and passed four amendments asking for further reviews, a form of action the States have perfected over several centuries.
That’s IT
The electronic voting system broke down twice on Thursday – another failed States IT project. The Bailiff said she thought it was ‘getting a little bit tired and grumpy’, the first time all week that anything in the building had been accused of sharing the public’s mood.
Find the Guernsey Deputy Scorecard at www.bridgeheadcommunications.com/guernsey.
You need to be logged in to comment.