Skip to main content
Peter Roffey

Peter Roffey

130 Articles
Subscriber Only

Beware of politicians bearing costly gifts

'The irony is that the same party showed laudable fiscal discipline recently, when in the tax debate they pushed for our general revenue reserves to be increased wherever possible’

Forward Guernsey madness / (Shutterstock 35037813)

Talk about yo-yo government.

Just weeks ago the States agreed, with little dissent, to increase employees’ social security contributions by 0.1%. That decision, in turn, was part of a 10-year plan to get contributions to the sort of levels the government actuary had advised were the minimum needed for the Guernsey Insurance Fund (GIF) to become sustainable in the long term.

Now, at the drop of an amendment, Forward Guernsey wants to unravel the last five years of progress on that programme. If they succeed, it will undermine the long-term viability of the GIF, which is the crucial fund from which the States pension is paid.

How irresponsible can you be? What a thing to do to the generations of islanders who will rely on the fund being there, with adequate funds, to pay their pensions in 20, 30 and 40 years’ time.

But it's all fine and dandy, says Guernsey’s only political party, implying that the GIF is in rude health. They say: ‘Since 2009, benefits paid out of the fund have exceeded contribution income collected, but investment returns on reserves of more than £800m. have resulted in growing annual surpluses.’

That’s all quite true, but what a fundamental misinterpretation. Their analysis is deeply flawed in two ways.

Firstly, it assumes that strong investment returns will be a permanent feature, when there is no such guarantee.

Secondly, the size of the fund, far from increasing in a way that might allow for such a partial contribution holiday, has actually fallen worryingly, when measured in the way the professionals use to assess such funds’ viability. That is by measuring how many years the fund could meet its obligations for if no more cash was put in.

For the avoidance of doubt, let me quantify exactly how great that recent decline in the ‘real funding level’ of the GIF has been. Figures from ESS show that the numbers of ‘years cover’ in the fund reduced from six years in 2010 to just 3.8 years in 2025. In the context of a fund designed to be there ultra- long term, serving successive generations, that is worrying. Why have the real funding levels been in such steep decline? Not only because the fund was initially falling in real terms, but also because, indeed mainly because, its obligations have been steadily growing. Thankfully that trend has now much improved thanks to the gradual increase in contribution levels over recent years.

Indeed, it now looks as if the GIF might manage to stay above what has always been regarded as the absolute minimum safe funding level – two years’ cover. But only if no one comes along and blows a hole in the long-term policy which brought about that required improvement.

Even if the GIF does retain its minimum two-year cover, the fact that the States acted so late, and allowed it to decline from its previous, much stronger, funding position is tragic. Not only in terms of its sustainability, but also in terms of what it means for future contributions levels.

The money which flows out of the fund, mainly to pay pensions every Friday, can only come from one of two sources. The first is investment returns and the other is current contributions. The better-funded the GIF, the more comes from investments, and therefore the less has to be taken out of workers’ pockets each month.

So because the Forward Guernsey amendment will inevitably lead to a smaller fund to invest in future, it will also mean lower investment returns, which in turn will necessitate higher contributions that would otherwise be the case.

Of course that’s not a narrative the political party is promoting. Rather they are touting their amendment as some sort of beneficent move to ease the cost-of-living crisis.

But then you should always beware of Greeks bearing gifts.

The irony is that the same party showed laudable fiscal discipline recently, when in the tax debate they pushed for our general revenue reserves to be increased wherever possible. Hats off to them for that, but where is the rationale in abandoning such prudence when it comes to the Guernsey Insurance Fund?

Sadly, the States doesn’t often manage to make difficult decisions. The 10-year plan to make the island’s pension fund sustainable was a notable and noble exception. To flip-flop on it now would be a disaster – and it would be pure populism.

Related  Politics

This content is restricted to subscribers. Already a subscriber? Log in here.

Get the Press. Get Guernsey.

Subscribe online & save. Cancel anytime.