Skip to main content
Subscriber Only

Proposal to move States meetings to St James

DISCUSSIONS are under way about the possibility of moving States meetings into St James.

Officials at St James have repeatedly warned that the venue could be forced to close without a substantial increase in funding. (Picture by Sophie Rabey, 35035134) / Guernsey Press

Details are being worked up by a group of deputies, led by Tom Rylatt, who have been encouraged by initial talks held with representatives from the concert hall.

The deputies believe that moving the States’ meeting chamber out of the Royal Court House and across the road could help secure the future of St James, which has been struggling financially for some years, as well as providing the island’s parliament with its own space and greater independence from the judiciary, but without the cost of constructing new buildings.

The proposal, which is at an early stage, would most likely involve the main Whittaker Hall hosting meetings of the States Assembly itself, and possibly the adjoining Dorey Centre being used as working space for States members and parliamentary staff.

Deputy Rylatt said he had given the idea ‘a fair amount of thought’, and he was encouraged by Education, Sport & Culture president Paul Montague saying he was ‘absolutely open’ to looking at new uses for St James, which is partially funded by a grant nominally overseen by his committee.

‘It began as a question about whether two long-standing issues – the considerable limitations of the current parliamentary estate, and St James’ sustainability – might have a mutually beneficial solution,’ said Deputy Rylatt.

‘Some of my Forward Guernsey colleagues and I have had very constructive discussions with representatives of St James about the practicalities and potential of whether parliamentary use could sit alongside its cultural and events role.

‘It has a strong civic history, a large main hall, supporting rooms, a public gallery and existing broadcasting capability. Parliamentary use could also potentially provide a more predictable income stream while allowing St James to continue as a cultural and community venue.’

Meetings of the States of Deliberation have been held at the Royal Court building for more than 200 years, but there have been many periods of discussion about the possibility of physically separating the parliament from the judiciary, as Jersey did in the late 19th century.

In 2000, the Harwood Panel, which reviewed the island’s machinery of government, advised that it ‘should no longer be acceptable’ for the States to share facilities with the Royal Court, and recommended that a purpose-built chamber should be created for meetings of the States, adjacent to rooms for committees and offices for deputies and a pool of research assistants. But that recommendation was rejected.

Two years ago, during the previous political term, States members backed a motion from Forward Guernsey party leader Gavin St Pier to have priority use of the Royal Court Chamber, a library next door and other limited space nearby. Some members want to take those moves much further, but recognise that public finances would preclude constructing a new parliamentary building.

‘I would not say I have definitively decided the States should move,’ said Deputy Rylatt.

‘My view is that it is worth exploring whether a separate parliamentary venue could better meet the States’ needs, relieve increasing pressure on the capacity of the Royal Court and contribute to St James’ long-term sustainability.

‘Given its clear potential advantages, my focus at present is specifically on whether St James presents a credible opportunity to accommodate and enable a more effective States. I haven’t considered alternative venues in any detail at this stage.’

Officials at St James have repeatedly warned that the venue could be forced to close without a substantial increase in funding.

St James receives about £70,000 a year from the States. An additional one-off sum of £150,000 was agreed last year. But it has said that about £215,000 a year would be needed to keep the venue going in the long term.

Deputy Montague said he had met representatives of St James several times since becoming ESC president in July last year.

‘What an amazing opportunity it is and what an amazing building it is,’ he said.

‘I think we should be open-minded. We shouldn’t be so stuck in our ways that we’re not willing to investigate some synergies in our island.

‘If we can be really efficient by looking at how we use that building, I am absolutely open to that idea.’

Deputy Rylatt indicated that there was support across the States for drawing up ‘a credible long-term plan’ for St James and welcomed Deputy Montague’s ‘openness to the idea of the States of Deliberation potentially playing a part in that’.

‘I am continuing to speak to relevant stakeholders and work through the practical, financial and operational questions. In due course, my Forward Guernsey colleagues and I will consider what formal next step, if any, should be taken,’ he said.

This content is restricted to subscribers. Already a subscriber? Log in here.

Get the Press. Get Guernsey.

Subscribe online & save. Cancel anytime.