Skip to main content

Campaigners win E&I backing to review tree protection orders

Tree protection rules are being reviewed by the States amid growing concerns that mature trees are being lost to development before planning applications are submitted.

Committee member Colin Dodd told the Guernsey Press that concerns had been building for years. / Peter Frankland/Guernsey Press

The Environment & Infrastructure Committee has asked its officials to examine whether the current system of tree protection orders remains fit for purpose. Findings are expected by spring next year.

The announcement follows Guernsey Trees for Life calling on deputies to introduce stronger legislation, including automatic protection for trees of a certain size or age and tougher penalties for deliberate damage. In a letter sent to all deputies this month, the charity warned that existing laws were failing to safeguard the island’s natural environment.

‘Right now, trees are usually only protected after they are already under threat or damaged,’ it said.

‘This leaves much of Guernsey’s most valuable green canopy unprotected against sudden felling or development.’

The charity said existing tree protection orders were reactive, slow and complex, with trees often lost before protection could be secured.

‘Whenever we raise these concerns with the States, we are told consistently that current laws do not give them the power to protect these trees and hedges.’

Committee member Colin Dodd told the Guernsey Press that concerns had been building for years, but the recent clearance of land near the airport had brought the issue to a head, leading to the letter.

He claimed some developers were removing trees and vegetation before submitting planning applications.

‘They buy the site, destroy everything on it, so when they put in a planning application, they can tick the box that says “no trees or environmental damage will be done in developing this site”,’ he said.

‘Which is quite right – because they’ve already done it.’

Mr Dodd said meetings with the presidents of E&I and the Development & Planning Authority had been encouraging, but he remained cautious about whether legislative change would follow.

‘I just want to start the process and start the discussion and just get people talking about it,' he said.

'I’m hopeful, but the States is always busy and always under-resourced.’

E&I president Adrian Gabriel said the committee was committed to protecting biodiversity while balancing environmental, social and economic needs, including providing housing.

‘Earlier this year, we asked officers for a review of the existing TPOs procedure to establish whether it remains fit for purpose in terms of protecting the island’s trees,’ he said.

‘This is part of a wider span of work by our committee to establish what the States can do to improve management of its own tree stock and whether further or alternative protections are required.’

However, he warned that introducing automatic protection could place additional demands on resources.

‘This could lead to a need to divert resources to monitor and enforce that legislation, which in the current economic climate may not be available,’ he said.

The committee was continuing to work with environmental groups, including Guernsey Trees for Life, and the DPA, he said, alongside progressing biodiversity net gain and wildlife legislation. Concerns about the practicality of the charity’s proposals have also been raised by chartered town planner Chris Crew, senior planning consultant at Collas Crill.

He drew comparisons with controversial tree protection proposals in Jersey, which he said were withdrawn last year following opposition from landowners, tree surgeons and politicians.

‘The practicality and additional cost of monitoring and enforcing “default protection limits” that automatically protect trees when they reach a certain size, age or specimen type has to be questioned,' he said.

He suggested a balanced approach would be to incorporate tree protection into wider environmental strategies rather than introduce blanket new planning controls.

Guernsey Trees for Life, which has the support of La Societe Guernesiaise and the National Trust in calling for change, said it wanted deputies to establish stronger protections during the current political term.

The Guernsey Nature Commission’s State of Nature report in 2024 noted that overall woodland in the island had increased significantly from 380 hectares in 2010 to 498 eight years later, mainly due to planting schemes and natural succession of scrub. But the island only has about 8% of woodland cover, lower than the UK average of 13.2%, and much of it was said to be in poor condition due to a lack of age and species diversity and the presence of non-native species, such as sycamore and Monterey Pine.

You need to be logged in to comment.