Skip to main content

Economic growth plan launched by Institute

GUERNSEY’S economy has grown at about a quarter of Jersey’s pace for a decade, and slow and reopened government decisions are the biggest reason why, according to local business leaders.

IoD committee member Jo Huxtable, IoD chairman Glen Tonks, president of Policy & Resources Lindsay de Sausmarez and CEO of KPMG Islands Group Neal Jehan on stage at yesterday’s IoD conference. (Picture by Peter Frankland, 35037999) / Guernsey Press

IoD Guernsey’s economic growth action plan, launched at its conference at Beau Sejour yesterday, said that real growth averaged 0.6% a year between 2013 and 2023, against 2.3% in Jersey.

Had Guernsey kept pace, the report estimated, the island would have produced about £643m. more output in 2023 alone.

The report draws on more than 280 contributions, including a survey of 127 business leaders. Of those, 91% said Guernsey was at an inflection point, and 57% named government decision-making as a top constraint on growth.

The States’ habit of making decisions and then reopening them was considered the biggest brake on the economy.

Business leaders described a system designed as though it had an executive but run as consensus government.

They said Policy & Resources had little leverage over committees, agreed plans could be reopened in the Assembly, and deputies were drawn into casework at the expense of strategy.

The tax debate was the example most often given.

‘The way our government is set up, it’s actually set up to tie themselves up and go round and round and round,’ one business leader told a workshop.

Another said issues were 'kicked down the road…so it looks like we’re doing something’.

IoD Guernsey chairman Glen Tonks said, in the report’s foreword, that Guernsey’s size should be an advantage.

‘A small, closely connected island can decide quickly and act together in ways that larger nations cannot.

‘Too often we do not act in this way, and the economy is growing more slowly than it should,’ he said.

The report made 10 recommendations, three of them aimed at the States.

It called for more homes and a faster permit route for talent, and a long-term growth plan with a fiscal framework to fund it.

It also wanted an independent review of how the States made decisions, reporting about nine months before the 2029 election so that every candidate could set out a position on it.

The final recommendation was to establish a growth taskforce of six members, four nominated by the G8 business bodies and two chosen by the IoD. It would have no budget and would advise rather than deliver anything.

Its terms of reference were due by the end of the year, with the taskforce in place by 31 January.

It also asked the States for a 10-to-15-year growth plan backed by an independently reviewed multi-year budget.

The IoD plans to repeat its survey next year and report on what has and has not moved.

You need to be logged in to comment.