Skip to main content

GST worries dominate responses to survey

FEARS that GST will make island life even less affordable dominated comments in a new cost-of-living survey.

Deputy Liam McKenna, a long-standing opponent of GST, said the survey findings reflected concerns he had been raising for years. (Picture by Sophie Rabey, 35041575) / Guernsey Press

The message from islanders struggling with the cost of living was clear in Island Global Research’s latest survey, with many respondents stating GST would only make their circumstances worse. The survey, which was conducted before the States voted in favour of the tax, found such fears were shared by both financially comfortable islanders and those already struggling to afford everyday essentials.

Respondents warned that GST could widen the gap between rich and poor, place further pressure on families and pensioners, and force more youngsters to leave the island.

Deputy Liam McKenna, a long-standing opponent of GST, said the findings reflected concerns he has been raising for years.

‘For the last seven years, I’ve campaigned "no to GST" because the prices we’re already paying in Guernsey are forcing our children and a generation away from the island, and you cannot tax a generation that no longer lives here,’ he said.

‘Everything is so unaffordable in Guernsey at the moment.’

The survey, completed by 1,137 Guernsey residents, found that 68% had noticed a major increase in their overall living expenses over the past year.

It also revealed that 11% could not afford their everyday costs and often went without essentials such as food and heating, while 42% could normally cover essentials but had little left for luxuries.

Although the survey did not specifically measure the proportion opposed to GST, the free-text comments were full of worry about its introduction.

One respondent, who said they could normally afford essentials, wrote: ‘GST is going to crumble us as a family and we will likely have to move off island somewhere with cheaper housing and groceries.’

Another, who described themselves as unable to afford their living costs, said: ‘GST will hit us pensioners hard as we spend all our pension on necessities.’

Even those who consider themselves financially comfortable raised concerns about the additional burden, with one stating: ‘GST will create more of a problem as all purchases will be affected, if States departments were more efficient with their spending, Guernsey wouldn’t be in such a state.’

The survey also found that 63% of respondents were very or extremely concerned about the current impact of living costs on their household, an increase of 10 percentage points compared with 2024.

Deputy McKenna said introducing GST would compound the pressure and warned that businesses could increase their prices by considerably more than the proposed 5% rate.

‘A £1 Mars bar at 5% would be £1.05. Well, it won’t be. It’ll be £1.30,’ he said.

‘That’s 30%. Or your tradespeople, they won’t put their fees up 5%. They’ll put it up 25, 30%. All of a sudden, what already is unaffordable becomes completely devastating.’

Deputy McKenna said he remained determined to oppose GST despite the States having voted in favour of the policy.

‘The game isn’t over yet,’ he said.

‘I will continually battle to stop the legislation going through. I know it’s unpopular. But I’ll try everything and anything possible to stop a GST which will then devastate this island.’

You need to be logged in to comment.