Skip to main content

‘This ‘fiscally incontinent’ States has flip-flopped yet again’

On 31 January 2026, the States of Guernsey voted to adopt a policy of reducing baseline public expenditure by 1% per year in real terms for the following three years – 2027-2029. The measure was approved during the debate on the Government Work Plan. Of the 34 deputies who voted, 29 voted in favour.

On 5 October 2026, an indecisive P&R was seemingly compelled to present two budgets to the SoG and deputies were asked to choose either Option A – similar to that voted – above –with that 25-9 majority – or Option B which increased committee spending by about £15.7m., representing a 1.3% rise in real terms – i.e. inflation +1.3%. So, 5.9% in nominal terms using RPI 4.6% for the 12 months to September 2026.

0n 6 November 2026, to most people’s surprise, the SoG adopted Option B – with only 12 deputies voting in favour of Option A – effectively the same proposal that 29 deputies voted for back in January 2026.

I am sure that some constitutionally-aware deputies will argue that the SoG did not permanently bind itself in January 2026 but this persistent flip-flopping by deputies is not a good look. How are non-parliamentarians supposed to know what constitutes a decision and what is simply guidance – not for debate here but it seems there were seven votes on GST before it was finally adopted. On the basis of the above, can the implementation of GST still be overturned?

Growth has become the latest SoG buzzword. We are told that the 2027 Budget is about growth rather than cuts, and Deputy Andy Niles described it as ‘fiscal good sense’. Perhaps. But economic growth cannot be voted into existence through higher public spending. If additional expenditure is absorbed by inflation and an expanding civil service, including 70 new posts, the result is likely to be a larger government rather than a larger economy.

Real growth comes from increasing productivity and removing obstacles to enterprise. In Guernsey, that means tackling housing shortages, addressing labour constraints and improving productivity across both the public and private sectors.

In short, it seems that this ‘fiscally incontinent’ States has flip-flopped yet again and voted to spend money it doesn’t have or is yet to receive, namely Pillar II and GST.

Eric Boyle
profithunter@yahoo.com

You need to be logged in to comment.