Skip to main content

AI has a place, but it needs to be kept there

Leaders founder Phil Eyre argues that we are in danger of outsourcing far too much to AI...

‘Excellence combines competence and character. Undoubtedly, AI can help us with competence. But it cannot contribute much to deepening our character. In fact, it likely detracts from it.’ / Picture supplied

Two years ago, I sat with a group of business leaders, drawn from across the world for a two-day closed conference on social capitalism. Two of the 30 in the group were at the forefront of AI advances. Naturally, their perspectives received serious attention. One of them worried about the social impact and potential harms of what AI could become. The other was downright scared.

‘It has the potential to be uncontrollable if we don’t put in safeguards now.’

If recent public statements by the heads of AI businesses are anything to go by, then it appears that he was right.

I’m grateful for technology. Machines, tools and apps help me to live an increasingly better life. I’m better connected than I’ve ever been. I can access any information I can think of. I can make plans in minutes, process data with ease, and communicate ideas in seconds. I’m up for anything that removes the drudgery of life: queuing in airport security, repeatedly filling in forms, meandering around the food shop to find the free-from section – all things that I’m looking forward to leaving behind, the sooner the better.

Yet I also look back with gratitude and pride: on tough moments faced with courage, on friendships and family, on helping to write a book, and on having an idea for something really cool in our business and then building it. I think, too, of calling a friend at a critical moment in their life, of spiritual experiences, and of working my way through the occasional existential crisis.

I think we are in danger of outsourcing far too much to AI. However fast-thinking these machines are, they cannot authentically create those qualities that make us truly human. True creativity, moral courage, authentic trust, honour, human excellence, deep relationships, love and activity that makes a genuine difference to others. These are the things that make us truly alive, that make us more than merely efficient, mechanistic beings. Yes, AI has a place, but it needs to be kept there.

Excellence combines competence and character. Undoubtedly, AI can help us with competence. But it cannot contribute much to deepening our character. In fact, it likely detracts from it.

The most sophisticated leaders are already grappling with this tension. Using AI to bounce off ideas, improve quality, process information, write code, and make plans is fine. But delegating our thinking and creativity thoughtlessly will eventually result in, well, less thought. AI has a way of telling us what we want to hear. Any CEO with narcissistic tendencies will always prefer the deferential and affirming guidance from whichever AI agent they use to the wisdom of other people.

‘Get comfortable being uncomfortable’ was a key takeaway from a Guernsey director during one of our recent workshops, focused on moral courage. Working through discomfort requires critical thinking, courage, often friendship, and social skills too. These qualities emerge only from friction and human effort. Seeking to remove all friction from life might feel nice in the short term but will lead to a shallow and arguably more fragile life.

Microsoft’s founder, Bill Gates, summarised it like this: ‘I doubt I would have put in the same work if I had had an AI companion back then. They talk to you in ways you’re already comfortable with… They are always available and never get mad at you. This gives them the potential to become highly addictive and to rob us of the lessons we learn from connecting with other people.’

Think about the last time you were inspired or moved. The chances are that it was a moment with real people doing truly amazing things. I don’t care if a robot can run faster than Usain Bolt or manufacture music that sounds like Mozart. It’s the appreciation for the struggle, discipline and talent that makes an experience truly inspiring. Outsourcing this to AI is like taking a helicopter to the top of a mountain. It’s not standing at the peak that matters the most. The real value is in the journey that it takes to get there.

Like any technology, if AI enables greater human performance, then bring it on. But it should never remove the struggles and tensions that make us, us. Without courage, character and meaningful connections, what are we?

You need to be logged in to comment.