Skip to main content
Subscriber Only

Vale officials criticise land planning policies

PARISH officials in the Vale have joined their St Sampson’s neighbours in a stinging criticism of land planning policies on the eve of a States debate on proposals to allocate sites for affordable housing – even though none of the sites newly proposed for housing are in their parish.

Vale Constable Richard Leale.
Vale Constable Richard Leale. / Guernsey Press

The Vale douzaine is writing to all deputies to raise ‘serious concerns about the scale and concentration of proposed housing developments in the north’. Half a dozen sites are already allocated, where up to 1,000 new homes could be built. It is warning that the combined impact on roads, drainage, local services and employment land needs to be properly assessed before changes to the Island Development Plan are approved.

Constable Richard Leale, on behalf of the constables and douzaine, has highlighted the proposals for up to 1,000 additional homes in a relatively small area, much of it low-lying or potentially vulnerable to flooding.

He said that the douzaine fully recognised the urgent need for more affordable housing in the island.

However, members believe that the requirement could be met more effectively by identifying a wider range of sites across the island, particularly locations where development could proceed more quickly, with less pressure on existing infrastructure, more open space and less additional traffic congestion.

‘Our position on this is quite straightforward – Guernsey needs more homes, particularly affordable homes, but the burden of providing them should be fairly distributed across the island, and development in the north must be supported by the infrastructure, safeguards and investment needed to make it sustainable for existing as well as future residents.’

Next Tuesday the States will be asked to agree the designation of new sites for affordable housing at Vazon, St Peter’s, St Martin’s, Forest and the Coutanchez. There are also two sites near the Vale, at Route Carre and L’Islet in St Sampson’s.

Vale officials remain concerned about the wider implications of the Island Development Plan, which sought to focus development within and around the edges of the urban centres of St Peter Port and St Sampson’s and the Vale.

Mr Leale said they were concerned that individual proposals are assessed largely on their own individual merits without a sufficiently clear picture of their combined impact on the Vale, particularly the major housing sites at Saltpans and Parc Le Lacheur, which together are expected to realise some 400 affordable homes.

The douzaine is calling for a proper assessment of the combined effect of these developments on traffic through L’Islet and the Bridge, pedestrian and cycling safety, school and commuter traffic, public transport and emergency-service access and has asked why consultants to the States have not already done this. The parish is also calling for a comprehensive assessment of the cumulative impact of the proposed developments, covering housing numbers, traffic, pedestrian safety, drainage, utilities, schools, community facilities and the loss and replacement of employment land.

The Vale also wants to see greater transparency about how deliverable the proposed housing sites really are.

Development & Planning Authority president Deputy Neil Inder has indicated that if plans for sites which might be approved by States members next week do not come forward for formal permission within 12 months, the designation will be rescinded.

The Vale said that it was clear that some sites had progressed much further than others, while sites such as Sandy Hook at L’Islet still required significant investigations into ground conditions and potential remediation costs.

Mr Leale said that there had to be clear deadlines and meaningful milestone requirements for developers, so that sites allocated for affordable housing did not remain undeveloped indefinitely.

E&I concerned on transport impact

ENVIRONMENT & Infrastructure appears to be on the same page as the Vale douzaine – it too has asked for the transport impact of any changes to the island’s planning rules to be assessed and costed across the whole island before they are put into effect.

An amendment to the States’ review of the Island Development Plan, to be debated next week, would direct E&I to identify the transport implications of any decisions arising from the review, and the resources needed to deliver a ‘whole-island transport response’, with any funding requests going first to the Policy & Resources Committee.

E&I president Adrian Gabriel and vice-president Sally Rochester will argue that land-use and transport planning are closely linked, and that decisions on housing, employment and retail development can significantly affect traffic, road capacity, parking demand, public transport and active travel. While the review will decide whether changes to planning policy are appropriate, the proposers say, it is ‘equally important to understand whether the island’s transport network can accommodate those changes and, if not, what interventions may be required’.

‘Planning decisions are most effective when supported by appropriate infrastructure,’ they said.

‘Understanding the transport consequences and resource requirements of IDP Review decisions will help ensure that any future development strategy can be delivered successfully, affordably and in a way that supports the wider interests of the island.’

This content is restricted to subscribers. Already a subscriber? Log in here.

Get the Press. Get Guernsey.

Subscribe online & save. Cancel anytime.