Two of the party’s members sit on ESS, but the other three deputies who make up the committee voted against the 0.5% cut when it was discussed at a meeting yesterday.
ESS president Tina Bury said her committee had ‘carefully considered’ Forward Guernsey’s amendment, which has been promoted as immediate relief against cost-of-living pressures, but ‘by a majority’ would advise deputies to reject it when social security contribution rates for 2027 are finalised at next week’s States Assembly sitting.
‘We fully recognise the pressures that the cost of living continues to place on islanders,’ said Deputy Bury.
‘However, the committee’s concern is that this proposal is not targeted towards those households experiencing the greatest financial pressure.
‘Analysis indicates that more than half of the £8-9m. of savings would go to the highest-income quarter of households, while lower-income households would receive a much smaller share.’
ESS said that cutting employee and self-employed contributions by 0.5% next year would result in a saving of about £215 for an average earner, but more than £1,000 for someone with earnings of £200,000.
It was not opposed to additional measures to alleviate pressure on household budgets, but wanted them to be ‘targeted towards lower- and middle-income households’.
The committee will press ahead with proposals to set contribution rates at 7.6% for employees and 12.6% for the self-employed, while Forward Guernsey will ask the States to set them at 7.1% and 12.1% respectively.
Most contribution income is paid into the Guernsey Insurance Fund, which pays the States pension and a handful of other contributory benefits. Since 2009, benefits paid out have exceeded income collected, but investment returns on reserves of more than £800m. have resulted in growing annual surpluses overall.
ESS was also concerned that an ongoing programme to increase contribution rates gradually could be undermined by Forward Guernsey’s amendment.
‘Returning to the agreed 10-year plan for increasing contribution rates in 2028 would require the employee rate to rise from 7.1% to 7.7% and the self-employed rate from 12.1% to 12.8% in a single year,’ said Deputy Bury.
‘If those increases were not considered feasible at that point, the result could be further lost income to the Guernsey Insurance Fund, and an even larger adjustment required in 2029 when the tax reforms are due to be implemented.’