Skip to main content
Subscriber Only

There is power in a union

UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham and his cabinet were in Brussels yesterday for an EU-UK summit aimed at ironing out new trade and migration agreements, as well as looking at food, energy and youth mobility, as part of the UK-EU ‘reset’. The summit was also of interest at Frossard House, where officers have spent months in negotiations with UK civil servants about what kind of new deal Guernsey can get with Europe. Peter Roffey reports

Prime Minister Andy Burnham, European Council president Antonio Costa and European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen outline the basics of the reset deal in Brussels yesterday. (35043339) / Supplied pic

THE Bailiwick was never part of the European Union, and so did not leave it when the UK did. But despite this, and Guernsey people having no vote on the matter, Brexit has had a fairly profound impact on island lives, and the economy. Why? Because our canny forefathers had negotiated a stonkingly good deal when the UK first went into the Common Market.

The British authorities at the time told the Crown Dependencies they expected us to join the trading bloc alongside them. For very good reasons we said ‘no’. But isolation would have been a pretty grim route to go down too. Cue Protocol Three of the Treaty of Rome.

Free movement of goods, and of most people, although locals without a UK/EU-born parent or grandparent lost out. And crucially exemption from alignment when it came to services – including financial services.

Our bread was buttered on both sides. Then came Brexit. Protocol Three was gone. Exporting or importing anything to/from the EU required a small mountain of paperwork. Our right to live in and work in the EU was severely curtailed. Any Guernsey business wanting to employ an EU citizen had to go through the process of trying to secure a British visa.

That is the history, but yesterday the situation changed again. Well, not yet, but forthcoming changes were announced at an EU summit.

Details of the long-awaited UK reset with the continental trading bloc were announced to the world. Understandably there was little focus on how it impacted Guernsey, but it looks like good news.

I sat down with Guernsey political lead for External Relations, Deputy Steve Falla, and the lead officer for the department, Jo Reeve, to understand exactly what will be changing, from as early as next year.

We also speculated on where Guernsey would stand if eventually Brexit was reversed altogether. What is contained in the reset agreement?

Jo Reeve: It has a few pillars to it. One is the Labour Party’s manifesto commitment for a veterinary agreement. That’s a sanitary-phytosanitary agreement, as it’s called in the trade. That’s the trade in food, animals, animal products, movements of animals like pets, and those sorts of things. It allows fewer checks to be done on food importation coming from the EU to the UK and vice versa. That’s quite a fundamental one. The second was an emissions trading scheme, but that doesn’t really cover us. The third was about mobility. Part of that was the Erasmus Plus scheme announced last year, and the other part is a youth experience scheme or youth mobility scheme for people between 18 and 30 to go and live and work in the EU for a fixed period. We’ll be able to benefit from that because we’re British and therefore will be covered by both Erasmus and the mobility scheme.

It sounds like it’s the free movement of goods, and young people, which will impact us most. In layman’s terms what is the sanitary-phytosanitary agreement?

JR: The SPS agreement is really looking to bring back what Protocol Three gave us in terms of trading goods, where we didn’t have to have these checks. Brexit meant more paperwork and we’ve had to implement some of that. The States made a decision in 2025 to build a new border model, but we haven’t actually done that because we’ve been waiting for this agreement to come along. It has, so we don’t now have to build a separate border model to control the import of food and agricultural products. We actually, we go back to the position of Protocol Three, where there’s much freer movement.

That is presumably a financial saving to the island as well. If we had had to rebuild that more complicated border model, there would have been costs involved?

JR: Definitely. In the UK, they’ve built a lot of border control posts, but a lot of that infrastructure will now be obsolete.

So what will be the practical impact of these changes?

JR: If you import food from the EU you normally have to have a veterinary use certificate. It costs about £200 for each shipment. The new deal reduces the requirement to have those certificates and goods can move without the kind of constant checks through the border that are required now. That will mean we have to align our food legislation with the EU’s, but that’s what we did under Protocol Three. The UK would like the agreement to take effect next year, so that its population will see the benefit of the price at the till.

Steve Falla: That will be true for us too. It will be really positive in terms of incoming food. Only recently, we were talking to Economic Development about the conversations they’ve been having with French suppliers, and with the new Cherbourg triangulation, and there are really good opportunities for bringing food in. This will reduce the amount of paperwork, make it more frictionless in terms of being able to bring stuff in from France. The other key thing to say is that this is we’re talking about goods, but we remain outside of the EU framework for services, and importantly, financial services are untouched by anything that might be agreed.

Those are the upsides. But you mentioned that we have to align various local standards with those in the EU. Could you give a practical example?

JR: I think novel foods is a good one because the CBD market has changed substantially since Brexit, and our position on it has been different since 2019 as well. So we’ll have to come into line with novel foods legislation, and with CBD products that are available in the EU at the moment. I think there’ll be a there’ll be a phase-in period of that over about three years.

At the time of Brexit, there was quite a lot of discussion about how it would impact the local fishing fleet. How will this reset impact them if at all?

JR: It won’t make any change on fishing. It does in terms of the export of the stuff you land and then export. But it doesn’t change landings into the EU or the fishing access arrangements negotiated under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement, which we then implemented the licensing regime. That’s all working very well.

But if in future, I don’t know, we had an export industry in octopi to EU countries then it would be easier – less paperwork?

JR: Yes, you could land them in Guernsey, then send them on a truck through the ferry without having to go through some of the checks you’d have to go through otherwise.

Before I leave the free movement of goods – what about the purity of the Guernsey cattle breed? Can we still protect it?

JR: Yes, there will be an import ban on bovine and bovine germinal products. That doesn’t really align with EU rules but it's been negotiated as an exception. It’s expressly listed in the agreement, so those bans can carry on, and that protects our breed. That was really important for us, a really important push, and so that’s good to see it in there. There won’t be any change in terms of milk and things like that. There will be no change to how we manage our dairy here and the milk imports, there’s no change to that.

How will these schemes work in relation to the free movement of young people?

JR: Well firstly there’s the Erasmus scheme. That’s when you go to university in the UK, and then you can take a year in the EU as part of your studies. So our students who are in UK universities can benefit from that and it’s going to be in operation imminently. Then there is the Youth Experience Scheme, which will effectively be free movement for those under 30. It’ll be for a fixed period, but we don’t expect it will be long enough for people to earn the right to live in Guernsey long-term.

Deputy Falla, you’ve had political oversight of this whole process. How would you describe the result?

SF: First, I’d like to say that we have a really strong team here. Working together as a team, we’ve been kept very well informed, and we’ve had continuous engagement at every opportunity, some at ministerial level, but a huge amount at officer level. With these sort of negotiations there are always hiccups along the way, but generally they’re able to be resolved, smoothed out, and that’s what our team have been particularly good at. So it’s good news for Guernsey, definitely. We’re definitely removing friction from the movement of goods. We’re enabling trade to work more fluidly. And in these days when we’re concerned about the security of food supply, the opportunity to bring food in from France is very positive. I think it’ll be it’ll make supply chains more reliable and hopefully more affordable.

And as the political lead what do you make of the free movement of young people?

SF: I think there’s an appetite among young people to travel more than in the past. It’s part of today’s youth culture to see and experience other parts of the world. So if young people from Guernsey are able to go and live and work relatively easily in parts of Europe, and also Europeans to come here, especially potentially in our hospitality industry, who are constantly needing more people, it can only be good.

To clarify one technical point. In the old days we had free movement to go and work in the EU, so long as we had a UK-born parent or grandparent. With the new under-30 scheme, is that is that necessary, or can every young Guernsey person do it?

JR: That distinction doesn’t exist any more. A British national is a British National, so it will be open to everyone.

So that all is good news as far as the UK reset with the EU is concerned, but of course all of the speculation is that Labour may include a full reversal of Brexit in their next manifesto. And the Lib Dems and Greens would support that too. What are the implications for Guernsey, and what work have you been doing to sort of prepare us for that possibility?

JR: The States of Guernsey did a lot of preparation in 2016, which is relevant to the debate that’s being had by the current UK Prime Minister. It’s not a political discussion involving us at the moment, just a debate that’s being had in the UK. There are four options that the Prime Minister has laid out recently in public. One is to stick with the reset just announced. Which is the kind of the Swiss arrangement. The next is the Customs union model, which is where the UK would be part of the Customs union, but not part of the single market. Then there’s the single market model, which is like the Norway model. Norway is part of the European Free Trade Area, and part of the European Economic Area. The last one is full entry of the UK back as a member state of the EU.

If that last one happened, where would it leave Guernsey politically? Is there any prospect of us ever becoming part of the EU? And if we weren’t, how what would we how would we define our relationship with the EU?

SF: The truth is, I don’t know. I doubt very much whether we would be able to continue to do business in the way that we’ve been used to, were we not to follow whatever decisions the UK took. Although we’re always able to carve out our own exceptions.

What sort of exceptions?

JR: The States’ objectives in 2016 were to pretty much maintain the status quo under Protocol Three, where we’re out for services, but in for the movement of goods. In the 1970s, when the UK was joining, we were focused on agricultural products going into the UK and some into the EU. Tomatoes were a massive part of our economy and we needed to access the UK market for that. But if we’d been dragged in with the UK, which is what the UK had tried to do in the late 1960s, early 70s, and said you have to join, then actually maintaining our domestic autonomy would be very difficult. So those same considerations would be part of the engagement with the UK if they were rejoining, trying to make sure that our interests were represented.

Obviously financial services is our biggest industry. I guess if we were full members, or part of the UK’s full membership of the EU, it would mean following their lead on the provision of services, which would have some implications?

JR: We’d have to align with all of the EU regulations for services, including financial services. It was very much was part of our policy position in 2016, and I think it applies now, that we wouldn’t want to be part of the EU for services because we like to retain our autonomy because that’s an important part of our USP in terms of where we are as a jurisdiction,

To end with a real flight of fancy. The UK not only rejoins, but they decided to adopt the euro as well. Where does that leave the Guernsey pound?

JR: I think the Prime Minister said Schengen and the euro would be off the table. But if the UK does then and joins the euro, we’d be picking up the dusty file from the late 90s and early 2000s when the Blair administration was looking at doing that, and then we’d have a choice to make about whether we wanted to align with that or do something different.

This content is restricted to subscribers. Already a subscriber? Log in here.

Get the Press. Get Guernsey.

Subscribe online & save. Cancel anytime.