In October last year the States said a full financial audit of the costly transition away from Agilisys was being carried out.
But in a new Freedom of Information response, the Policy & Resources Committee has confirmed there was no audit – only an internal financial review – and that the word ‘audit’ had been used in error.
‘The exercise undertaken was a financial review and there was no separate formal audit process,’ the committee said. It confirmed there were no formal terms of reference, no recorded start or completion date, no independent or external involvement and no formal sign-off.
‘Accordingly, there is no standalone “full financial audit” report to disclose,’ it said.
The admission came in reply to a follow-up request seeking to reconcile and verify the figures released by the States when it set out in early October what ending the Agilisys contract and replacing it with a ‘multi-vendor model’ had cost.
Those responses disclosed £652,000 in external legal fees for terminating the contract alongside £3.3m. of one-off set-up costs, £10.1m. of supplier spending in the first year, and an estimated £38.5m. cost for the new model over four years.
The committee declined to release the workings behind two of its key reassurances. It has previously said the approach taken avoided around £5m. of exit and transition costs, and that the multi-vendor model was expected to cost ‘broadly the same’ as continuing with Agilisys. But it withheld the calculations, assumptions and comparison behind both, citing exemptions covering commercial and contractual interests and internal deliberation.
‘The States confirms that analysis was undertaken during the transition comparing the anticipated cost of the multi-vendor model with the cost of continuing with the former Agilisys service arrangement,’ the committee said, though it added that the comparison ‘was not strictly like-for-like’.
The States also stood by its claims that the new model had delivered fewer outages, stronger security, more stable services and a shift in user feedback ‘from negative to positive’ – but refused to release the performance reports, scorecards or dashboards behind them, again citing commercial confidentiality.
It went on to acknowledge that, more than a year after the switch, there was still no single system for monitoring how its various IT suppliers are performing.
‘It is also important to clarify that supplier performance information is not currently received or maintained in a single, consistently aggregated reporting format,’ P&R said.
‘Establishing greater consistency across multi-vendor performance reporting is a future objective as the operating model continues to mature.’
The committee said it had sought to balance transparency with the need to protect commercial, contractual and security interests, and that the new model was still maturing, including through ‘more consistent financial and performance reporting’.
The 10-year strategic partnership inked with Agilisys Guernsey was originally valued at around £200m., though it was terminated by the States halfway through in July 2025 due to performance concerns.
You need to be logged in to comment.